Top pick:Trattoria Pallottino, best for: Diners seeking traditional Tuscan specialties. 351 m from the centre of Florence.
Also near the top:La Spada Osteria, best for: Diners seeking authentic Tuscan grilled meats; and La Beppa Fioraia, best for: Diners seeking authentic Tuscan cuisine.
How it was ranked:10 restaurants compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%). Each verdict is below.
Best Italian restaurants in Florence: Top 10 Ranked. Trattoria Pallottino ranks first, with a Lister Score of 84.0.
Trattoria Pallottino leads this ranking: it features a visible kitchen where guests watch dishes being prepared. La Spada Osteria cooks prized cuts like Bistecca alla fiorentina on an open grill. La Beppa Fioraia offers generous platters and grilled meats from a trusted butcher.
Best Italian Restaurants in Florence in 2026, compared
Trattoria Lo Stracotto serves authentic Tuscan dishes using local suppliers and high-quality ingredients. It offers a rich menu of typical regional cuisine for lunch and dinner.
PROS
The restaurant uses only local suppliers and high-quality raw materials.
The restaurant provides gluten-free product options for customers.
Tamerò offers a unique culinary experience in Florence featuring fresh pasta and ancient grain pizzas. The menu combines Italian dishes with innovative cocktails and modern mixology.
PROS
The restaurant serves fresh pasta made from selected ancient grains.
The restaurant transforms the aperitivo into an art form with stuzzichini.
Libreria Brac is a contemporary art bookshop in Florence that also serves coffee and cuisine. It operates as a cultural hub hosting regular literary events and meetings.
PROS
The restaurant offers a unique combination of a contemporary art library and dining.
Libreria Brac hosts a regular programme of literary events and author meetings.
Best for
Art and literature enthusiasts
Where it falls short
It does not offer a standard restaurant-only dining experience without the library context.
Pick something else if
you want a traditional Italian restaurant setting.
What are the best Italian restaurants in Florence?
Trattoria Pallottino ranks first on Lister. Guests can enjoy traditional Tuscan specialties passed down through generations.
What are the top 10 Italian restaurants in Florence?
1. Trattoria Pallottino; 2. La Spada Osteria; 3. La Beppa Fioraia; 4. Amici di Ponte Vecchio Da Stefano; 5. Mastro Ciliegia; 6. Trattoria Lo Stracotto; 7. Trattoria Angiolino Ai 13 Arrosti; 8. Tamerò; 9. Libreria Brac; 10. il Grande Nuti.
What do the top four say they focus on?
Trattoria Pallottino offers a wide selection of local wines to accompany the meal, and La Spada Osteria serves authentic Tuscan dishes prepared with genuine ingredients. La Beppa Fioraia serves handmade pasta and traditional sweets reflecting authentic Tuscan flavours, and Amici di Ponte Vecchio Da Stefano creates original and daring food pairings to surprise its customers.
What should a buyer check before signing up?
Trattoria Pallottino states that the restaurant is closed on Mondays, limiting availability for weekly dining plans. Those are the limits each restaurant publishes itself, not a full account of any plan.