Top pick:Ave Mario, best for: pre-show dining. 464 m from the centre of London, part of bigmammagroup.com.
Also near the top:Barbarella, best for: cinematic dining experiences; and Clos Maggiore, best for: romantic anniversary dinners.
How it was ranked:10 restaurants compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%). Each verdict is below.
Best Italian restaurants in London: Top 10 Ranked. Ave Mario ranks first, with a Lister Score of 100.0.
Ave Mario comes first on this list for pre-show dining, and welcomes children and provides high chairs upon request. Barbarella is built for cinematic dining experiences, and boasts an extensive selection of Brunello di Montalcino wines. Clos Maggiore serves romantic anniversary dinners, and features a famous blossom-adorned conservatory for al-fresco dining.
Best Italian Restaurants in London in 2026, compared
RANK
ENTRY
BEST FOR
SCORE
1
Ave Mario464 m from the centre of London, part of bigmammagroup.com
pre-show dining
100.0
2
Barbarella2.3 km from the centre of London, part of bigmammagroup.com
Each entry's Lister Score on this ranking weighs fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%).
A 1970s retro-futuristic Italian dining escape in Canary Wharf
Barbarella is a cinematic Italian restaurant and pizzeria located in Canary Wharf. It offers a retro-futuristic escape inspired by the glory days of Cinecittà.
Award-winning authentic Italian dining across two unique floors
Bocconcino Mayfair operates two distinct dining spaces in London's Mayfair district. The restaurant unites these areas through consistent first-class service and authentic Italian cooking.
PROS
The restaurant serves fresh seafood and handmade pasta prepared daily by the kitchen team.
The restaurant offers an extensive wine list featuring over three hundred Italian bottles.
CONS
The restaurant restricts guests under eighteen from accessing the lower ground floor after five pm.
Best for
anniversary dinners and private corporate events
Where it falls short
Guests under eighteen cannot access the lower ground floor after five pm.
Pick something else if
you need a family-friendly venue with late-night seating for minors.
Bardo St James's offers refined Italian dining with crafted cocktails and live music. It creates an elegant atmosphere where every night feels like a special occasion.
PROS
The restaurant serves handmade pasta and delicate seafood shaped by the season.
The restaurant provides live jazz piano and upbeat weekend sets for guests.
Best for
pre-theatre diners
Where it falls short
The menu is shaped by the season, so availability of specific dishes changes frequently.
Pick something else if
you need a fixed menu with consistent year-round offerings.
Bocca Di Lupo is a family-run trattoria in Soho serving honest regional Italian cuisine. It specialises in obscure highlights from all twenty regions of Italy.
PROS
The restaurant makes its own gelati, breads and pasta in-house.
The restaurant offers a private dining room for up to thirty two seated guests.
Best for
post-theatre dining
Where it falls short
It is unavailable during the Christmas holiday period.
Dehesa is a charcuterie and tapas bar inspired by the cuisine and wines of Spain and Italy. It offers a friendly atmosphere with Spanish flair in the heart of Soho.
PROS
The restaurant features the largest heated corner terrace in Soho.
Dehesa provides an on-site sommelier to guide wine pairings.
Ember Yard is a charismatic tapas restaurant in Soho specialising in wood-fired Spanish and Italian dishes. It offers small sharing plates crafted with locally sourced ingredients.
PROS
The restaurant creates exceptional small and large sharing plates.
The restaurant provides a semi-private room for events.
Best for
sharing plates and cocktails
Pick something else if
you require a fully enclosed private event space.
79.9
Put your company on this ranking
Contact us about one, two or three years. Nothing recurring.
Ave Mario ranks first on Lister. Ave Mario features high ceilings and a retro atmosphere while serving authentic Italian cuisine.
What are the top 10 Italian restaurants in London?
1. Ave Mario; 2. Barbarella; 3. Clos Maggiore; 4. Bocconcino Mayfair; 5. Icco Goodge Street; 6. Bardo St James's; 7. Bocca Di Lupo; 8. Dehesa; 9. Bancone; 10. Ember Yard.
What do the top four say they are built for?
Ave Mario says it is built for pre-show dining, and Barbarella for cinematic dining experiences. Clos Maggiore says it is built for romantic anniversary dinners, and Bocconcino Mayfair for anniversary dinners and private corporate events.
What should a buyer check before signing up?
Ave Mario states that the restaurant does not offer gluten-free pasta or pizza options, and Barbarella that the restaurant does not allow guests to bring their own cake or alcoholic beverages. Bocconcino Mayfair states that the restaurant restricts guests under eighteen from accessing the lower ground floor after five pm. Those are the limits each restaurant publishes itself, not a full account of any plan.