Top pick:IL Gambero, best for: Families and event planners. 1.3 km from the centre of Melbourne.
Also near the top:Universal Italian, best for: takeaway and delivery customers; and Ronnie's, best for: family dinners.
How it was ranked:10 restaurants compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%). Each verdict is below.
Best Italian restaurants in Melbourne: Top 10 Ranked. IL Gambero ranks first, with a Lister Score of 93.1.
IL Gambero comes first on this list: it offers high-quality food at great value. Universal Italian is built for takeaway and delivery customers, and serves its real famous chicken parma to diners. Ronnie's serves family dinners, and provides flexible spaces suitable for various events and budgets.
Best Italian Restaurants in Melbourne in 2026, compared
Sopranos (#8): diners seeking vibrant Italian dining
Rosa's Canteen (#9): diners seeking authentic home-style Italian meals
Each entry's Lister Score on this ranking weighs fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%).
Italian gastronomy presented as a special dining show
Teatro is a Southbank pizzeria and bar offering Italian cuisine alongside the Yarra River. It provides a dining experience that blends traditional flavours with home comforts.
PROS
The restaurant offers a weekly Winter Warmer menu featuring slow-cooked dishes like lasagna and osso buco.
The restaurant serves an authentic aperitivo board with various cured meats and cheeses.
Best for
celebrations and corporate events
Where it falls short
Groups of fourteen or more people incur a mandatory ten percent service charge.
Fresh quality pizza, pasta and Italian mains served in Southbank
Sopranos Pizza Pasta serves fresh quality pizza, pasta and Italian mains in Southbank. The restaurant offers a vibrant and luminous dining environment for its guests.
PROS
The restaurant serves fresh quality pizza, pasta and Italian mains.
Sopranos provides a vibrant and luminous atmosphere for customers.
Best for
diners seeking vibrant Italian dining
Where it falls short
It is located only in Southbank, limiting access for diners elsewhere in Melbourne.
Traditional Italian cuisine with a Sicilian lean in Melbourne
Rosa's Canteen serves traditional Italian cooking with a Sicilian lean from Rosa Mitchell's kitchen. She cooks the food she grew up with, offering wholesome dishes built on local produce.
PROS
The restaurant offers wholesome dishes built on fresh local ingredients.
The restaurant welcomes large bookings and provides separate service for groups of eight or more.
CONS
The restaurant is closed on weekends, limiting dining options to weekdays only.
Best for
diners seeking authentic home-style Italian meals
Where it falls short
It is closed on weekends, limiting dining options to weekdays only.
Universal Italian says it is built for takeaway and delivery customers, and Ronnie's for family dinners. Teatro says it is built for celebrations and corporate events, and +39 Pizzeria for groups of eight or more people.
What should a buyer check before signing up?
Universal Italian states that the restaurant does not take a la carte reservations, and Ronnie's that the restaurant operates as a cashless venue only. Rosa's Canteen states that the restaurant is closed on weekends, limiting dining options to weekdays only. Those are the limits each restaurant publishes itself, not a full account of any plan.