Top pick:North Italia, best for: Diners seeking fresh pasta. 992 m from the centre of Miami.
Also near the top:Joey's Italian Cuisine, best for: Diners seeking daily changing roasted meats; and Felice Brickell, best for: warm neighborhood gatherings.
How it was ranked:10 restaurants compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%). Each verdict is below.
Best Italian restaurants in Miami: Top 10 Ranked. North Italia ranks first, with a Lister Score of 82.2.
North Italia ranks first here: it prepares fresh pasta daily for its customers. Joey's Italian Cuisine uses traditional techniques to slow-roast finest local ingredients. Felice Brickell is built for warm neighborhood gatherings, and provides warm hospitality and hand-made pasta in a welcoming setting.
Best Italian Restaurants in Miami in 2026, compared
Each entry's Lister Score on this ranking weighs fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%).
North Italia is an Italian restaurant in Miami offering fresh pasta made daily and a variety of pizzas. The menu features shareable starters, salads, and specialty dishes alongside a selection of cocktails.
Joey's Italian Cuisine offers authentic Italian rosticceria featuring masterfully roasted meats and fresh salads. It provides hearty sandwiches in a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Authentic italian dining and la dolce vita in Miami Beach
Donatella Restaurant is a culinary gem redefining dining in Miami Beach. It blends timeless Italian glamour with a lively atmosphere within the boutique hotel.
PROS
The restaurant offers traditional dishes crafted from fresh seasonal ingredients.
The restaurant features daily Italian aperitivo with signature cocktails and bites.
CONS
The restaurant operates on limited days, closing Monday to Wednesday.
Best for
Diners seeking traditional Italian cuisine
Where it falls short
The restaurant operates on limited days, closing Monday to Wednesday.
Executive Chef Scott Brown leads the culinary vision at Gianni’s Restaurant at The Villa Casa Casuarina, the iconic Former Versace Mansion in Miami Beach.
PROS
The restaurant blends classic techniques with premium ingredients and South Florida influences.
The restaurant offers unique dining spaces including a mosaic pool area.
CONS
Reservations do not guarantee poolside seating as tables remain subject to availability.
Best for
Diners seeking unique mosaic pool settings
Where it falls short
Reservations do not guarantee poolside seating as tables remain subject to availability.
A diverse menu of pizzas, pastas, and subs in Miami Beach.
Pizza Fiore is a Miami Beach establishment offering online ordering with discounts. It provides a comprehensive menu of Italian favourites and American classics.
PROS
The restaurant offers extensive customisation for its pizza selections.
The restaurant serves a wide variety of pasta dishes and subs.
Best for
Groups seeking varied Italian and casual dining options
Authentic Italian pizza in the heart of Miami Beach
Pizza Rustica South Beach is a Miami-based pizzeria offering online ordering with discounts. It specialises in a wide variety of Italian-style pizzas and slices.
PROS
The restaurant offers premium meat pizzas with high-quality ingredients like Fontanini pepperoni.
The restaurant provides an extensive range of gluten-free options made with rice flour.
Best for
pizza lovers seeking diverse toppings
Where it falls short
Many items are currently unavailable for purchase.
North Italia ranks first on Lister. North Italia is an Italian restaurant in Miami offering fresh pasta made daily and a variety of pizzas. The menu features shareable starters, salads, and specialty dishes alongside a selection of cocktails.
What are the top 10 Italian restaurants in Miami?
1. North Italia; 2. Joey's Italian Cuisine; 3. Felice Brickell; 4. Macchialina; 5. Cafe Prima Pasta; 6. Donatella Restaurant; 7. Gianni’s At The Villa; 8. Pizza Fiore; 9. Pizza Rústica; 10. Forte Dei Marmi.
Who are these italian restaurants built for?
Felice Brickell says it is built for warm neighborhood gatherings, and Macchialina for date nights. Pizza Fiore says it is built for Groups seeking varied Italian and casual dining options, and Pizza Rústica for pizza lovers seeking diverse toppings.
What should a buyer check before signing up?
Cafe Prima Pasta states that OpenTable reservations do not guarantee specific seating locations, and Donatella Restaurant that the restaurant operates on limited days, closing Monday to Wednesday. Gianni’s At The Villa states that Reservations do not guarantee poolside seating as tables remain subject to availability. Those are the limits each restaurant publishes itself, not a full account of any plan.