Key takeaways
- Top pick: Stellina, best for: Diners seeking handmade pasta and wine. 788 m from the centre of Montreal.
- Also near the top: Da Vinci, best for: smart or smart/casual dinners; and Il Teatro (Quartier des spectacles), best for: Diners seeking covered heated terraces.
- How it was ranked: 10 restaurants compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%). Each verdict is below.
Best Italian restaurants in Montreal: Top 10 Ranked. Stellina ranks first, with a Lister Score of 83.0.
Stellina comes first on this list: it prepares fresh pasta by hand every day.
Da Vinci is built for smart or smart/casual dinners, and provides distinguished wines and signature cocktails.
Il Teatro (Quartier des spectacles) features an inspired wine cave.
Not on this ranking?Tell us about your company and we will reply by email.
How to choose
Start from what you need it for. Where each entry fits best:
Each entry's Lister Score on this ranking weighs fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%).
Each entry's full verdict is below.
The ranking, in detail
01

An Italian experience in the heart of Old Montreal
Chef Jonathan Agnello leads Stellina with a focus on exceptional execution and prestigious ingredients. The restaurant honours old-world Italian roots through daily fresh pasta and seasonal produce.
PROS- The restaurant prepares fresh pasta by hand every day.
- Stellina offers an exceptional wine cellar featuring Italian wines and grand crus.
CONS- The restaurant does not allow guests to bring their own cakes or outside food.
- Best for
- Diners seeking handmade pasta and wine
- Where it falls short
- Guests cannot bring their own cakes or outside food.
- Pick something else if
- you need to bring your own cake.
83.0
02

Authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Montreal
Ristorante Da Vinci is an authentic Italian restaurant in Montreal. It offers refined cuisine with a variety and quality sought by diners.
PROS- The restaurant serves excellent food including European bass and lamb chops.
- Da Vinci provides distinguished wines and signature cocktails.
- Best for
- smart or smart/casual dinners
- Where it falls short
- It is closed on Sundays and Mondays, limiting availability for weekend or early-week dining.
- Pick something else if
- you need to dine on Sundays or Mondays.
82.5
03

An incomparable dining experience with fine cuisine
Il Teatro offers contemporary Italian cuisine in Quebec City and Montreal. It is located at the Carré des spectacles and Quartier des spectacles.
PROS- The restaurant features an inspired wine cave.
- The restaurant provides a covered heated terrace.
- Best for
- Diners seeking covered heated terraces
82.0
04

Authentic Italian dining in Montreal for nearly 30 years
Wienstein & Gavino's crafts fresh pasta daily using finest ingredients. The restaurant captures bold Italian flavours with care.
PROS- Wienstein & Gavino's serves housemade pasta crafted fresh each day.
- The restaurant offers an impressive selection of craft cocktails and wines.
- Best for
- Diners seeking fresh pasta and drinks
80.8
05

Authentic Pugliese cuisine by certified Italian chefs and professional bakers
La Panzeria is an authentic Italian café located in Montreal's Plateau-Mont-Royal district. It serves traditional cuisine from the Puglia region of southern Italy.
PROS- The restaurant offers handmade pasta and homemade desserts.
- The restaurant provides online ordering and delivery services.
- Best for
- Families and online orderers
- Where it falls short
- It is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.
- Pick something else if
- you need service on those days.
80.4
06

Peruvian restaurant in Montreal
Restaurant Miraflores is a Peruvian establishment located in Montreal's Plateau district. It offers gastronomy rich in flavour from Peru.
PROS- The restaurant serves a wide variety of seafood and Peruvian specialties.
- The restaurant provides private event reception services for guests.
CONS- The restaurant does not accept reservations via its online contact form.
- Best for
- Groups seeking private event reception services
- Where it falls short
- The restaurant does not accept reservations via its online contact form.
- Pick something else if
- you need to book a table using the online form.
79.8
07

An institution since 2013
Le Serpent offers Italian-inspired dishes within a contemporary brasserie setting.
PROS- The restaurant features a high-quality wine list.
- The restaurant displays major contemporary artworks.
- Best for
- Wine and art enthusiasts
79.5
08

Italian by nature, Japanese by love
Tiramisu serves classic Italian dishes ingeniously crafted with Japanese flavours. It has won over locals and travellers in Chinatown.
PROS- The restaurant offers unique fusion dishes like Tonokotsu lasagne.
- The restaurant provides a stylish mid-century atmosphere with Japanese influences.
- Best for
- group events
- Pick something else if
- you want standard Italian food.
78.2
09

Authentic Romapolitan pizza and homemade pasta in Old Montreal
Bevo Bar-Pizzeria is an Italian restaurant located in the heart of Old Montreal. It features an elegant two-storey setting with a warm and festive atmosphere.
PROS- The restaurant serves fresh homemade pasta and wood-fired pizzas.
- The restaurant offers a selection of acclaimed Italian wines.
CONS- Terrace reservations are not guaranteed for customers.
- Best for
- Diners seeking wood-fired pizzas
- Where it falls short
- Terrace reservations are not guaranteed for customers.
- Pick something else if
- you require a guaranteed outdoor dining spot.
70.9
10

Dining experience in Montreal
Terracotta is a restaurant located in Montreal. It offers dining services to its patrons.
PROS- The restaurant provides a dedicated dining space for customers.
- Terracotta serves food within the city of Montreal.
- Best for
- Diners seeking a dedicated space
67.4
Put your company on this ranking
Contact us about one, two or three years. Nothing recurring.
Positions #4 to #10 are available on request. Contact us.
Not on this ranking?Tell us about your company and we will reply by email.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best Italian restaurants in Montreal?
Stellina ranks first on Lister. Chef Jonathan Agnello leads Stellina with a focus on exceptional execution and prestigious ingredients. The restaurant honours old-world Italian roots through daily fresh pasta and seasonal produce.
What are the top 10 Italian restaurants in Montreal?
1. Stellina; 2. Da Vinci; 3. Il Teatro (Quartier des spectacles); 4. Wienstein & Gavino's; 5. La Panzeria; 6. Restaurant Miraflores; 7. Le Serpent; 8. Tiramisu; 9. Bevo Bar-Pizzeria; 10. Terracotta.
What do the top four say they focus on?
Stellina offers an exceptional wine cellar featuring Italian wines and grand crus, and Da Vinci serves excellent food including European bass and lamb chops. Il Teatro (Quartier des spectacles) provides a covered heated terrace, and Wienstein & Gavino's serves housemade pasta crafted fresh each day.
What should a buyer check before signing up?
Stellina states that the restaurant does not allow guests to bring their own cakes or outside food, and Restaurant Miraflores that the restaurant does not accept reservations via its online contact form. Bevo Bar-Pizzeria states that terrace reservations are not guaranteed for customers. Those are the limits each restaurant publishes itself, not a full account of any plan.
Sources
Where we checked each company's facts, and when.
Sources for 5 more companies
Some links on Lister are affiliate links. Rankings are not affected.
Related rankings