Curated top 10 rankings of everything
HOME/RESTAURANTS/NEW YORK/ITALIAN RESTAURANTS IN NEW YORK

Best Italian Restaurants in New York in 2026

10 restaurants ranked, each with a short verdict.

Updated · How we rank

VERIFIEDLISTER SCORE · UPDATED Get your company ranked

Key takeaways

  • Top pick: Coletta Italian Vegan Restaurant, best for: Vegan and kosher diners. 3.8 km from the centre of New York.
  • Also near the top: Da Claudio, best for: Diners seeking homemade pasta and sustainable seafood; and Ainslie Bowery, best for: Private events and large groups.
  • How it was ranked: 10 restaurants compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%). Each verdict is below.

Best Italian restaurants in New York: Top 10 Ranked. Coletta Italian Vegan Restaurant ranks first, with a Lister Score of 88.1.

Coletta Italian Vegan Restaurant takes the top spot on this list: it offers distinct Italian flavours including brick oven pizzas. Da Claudio serves sustainable seafood and curated Italian wines. Ainslie Bowery is built for Private events and large groups, and features twenty thousand square feet across five distinct spaces.
Best Italian Restaurants in New York in 2026, compared
RANKENTRYBEST FORSCORE
1Coletta Italian Vegan Restaurant3.8 km from the centre of New York–88.1
2Da Claudio252 m from the centre of New York–84.0
3Ainslie Bowery1.4 km from the centre of New YorkPrivate events and large groups82.7
4Da Nico1.1 km from the centre of New Yorkfamilies and couples seeking authentic Italian dining81.9
5Carbone1.8 km from the centre of New York–79.4
6Fossetta1.8 km from the centre of New York–77.2
7Fiat Café1.3 km from the centre of New York–73.1
8Bacaro1.2 km from the centre of New Yorklingering conversations69.3
9Bevacco1.9 km from the centre of New Yorkgroups of six or more69.0
10Eataly - SoHo1.2 km from the centre of New York, part of eataly.comItalian food enthusiasts67.6
CURATED · UPDATED HOW WE RANK →
Not on this ranking?

Tell us about your company and we will reply by email.

How to choose

Start from what you need it for. Where each entry fits best:

  • Ainslie Bowery (#3): Private events and large groups
  • Da Nico (#4): families and couples seeking authentic Italian dining
  • Bacaro (#8): lingering conversations
  • Bevacco (#9): groups of six or more
  • Eataly - SoHo (#10): Italian food enthusiasts

Each entry's Lister Score on this ranking weighs fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%).

Each entry's full verdict is below.

The ranking, in detail

01

Coletta Italian Vegan Restaurant

Vegan and kosher Italian Restaurant in Gramercy, NYC

Coletta is an intimate vegan and kosher dining experience in Gramercy, NYC. It offers a fresh culinary perspective on Italian cuisine with brick oven pizzas and fresh pastas.

PROS
  • The restaurant serves entirely vegan and kosher certified Italian cuisine.
  • The restaurant offers distinct Italian flavours including brick oven pizzas.
Best for
Vegan and kosher diners
Where it falls short
Parties of six or more incur an automatic twenty percent gratuity.
Pick something else if
you prefer no mandatory service charges for large groups.
88.1
02

Da Claudio

An Italian rebirth in Lower Manhattan

Da Claudio produces fresh, seasonal fare using local produce and Italian imports. The restaurant sources meats and vegetables from upstate New York farms.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers homemade pastas and thoughtfully crafted cocktails.
  • Da Claudio serves sustainable seafood and curated Italian wines.
Best for
Diners seeking homemade pasta and sustainable seafood
Where it falls short
The menu relies heavily on imported ingredients rather than fully local sourcing.
Pick something else if
you prioritize exclusively domestic farm-to-table dining.
84.0
03

Ainslie Bowery

Where every night is an event

Ainslie Bowery is a multi-level Italian dining venue in the Lower East Side. It offers wood-fired pizzas and house-made pastas alongside an extensive beverage programme.

PROS
  • The restaurant features twenty thousand square feet across five distinct spaces.
  • The restaurant provides non-alcoholic cocktails and de-alcoholised wines during happy hour.
Best for
Private events and large groups
Where it falls short
It is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, limiting availability for those dining mid-week.
Pick something else if
you need to dine on Monday or Tuesday.
82.7
04

Da Nico

A taste of Italy in New York City

Da Nico specialises in handmade pasta and brick oven pizza at its Mulberry Street location.

PROS
  • The restaurant uses a signature brick oven for authentic Neapolitan cooking.
  • The restaurant offers a beautiful outdoor garden for al fresco dining.
Best for
families and couples seeking authentic Italian dining
81.9
05

Carbone

The original celebrated Italian-American dining experience in New York City

Carbone is a celebrated Italian restaurant in New York City offering quintessential dining. It features charismatic service with captains in tuxedos on historic Thompson Street.

PROS
  • The restaurant emphasizes top-quality ingredients and honours culinary traditions.
  • The restaurant fosters an intimate atmosphere with rich burgundy leather banquettes.
CONS
  • The restaurant may refuse entry to guests who are not sufficiently well-presented.
Best for
Diners seeking intimate, traditional Italian dining
Where it falls short
It may refuse entry to guests who are not sufficiently well-presented.
Pick something else if
you prefer a casual dress code.
79.4
06

Fossetta

Italian cooking meets a relaxed, neighbourhood feel

Fossetta is an intimate Lower East Side restaurant where Italian cooking meets a relaxed, neighbourhood feel. Led by industry veterans Julie Park and Charlene Santiago, the menu draws from Mediterranean flavours.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers a thoughtful selection of wines and beautifully crafted cocktails.
  • Fossetta accommodates large parties and private events with dedicated planning support.
Best for
Groups hosting large parties
77.2
07

Fiat Café

A pinch of Italy and a dash of France in Nolita

This Nolita establishment offers a blend of Italian and French influences within a distinctive pink interior.

PROS
  • The restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner continuously from 8am to 10:30pm.
  • The restaurant provides heated outdoor seating on the sidewalk for guests.
Best for
Diners seeking all-day Italian meals
Where it falls short
Weekend brunch and Friday to Saturday dinners fill up quickly.
Pick something else if
you need guaranteed seating without booking in advance.
73.1
08

Bacaro

A quiet block transporting you to Italy on Division Street

The venue features rustic decor with wooden tables and exposed brick walls.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers an authentic Italian atmosphere away from the city bustle.
  • Bacaro provides online ordering options via Grubhub and DoorDash.
Best for
lingering conversations
Where it falls short
It is closed on Mondays, limiting availability for weekly dining plans.
Pick something else if
you need a restaurant open seven days a week.
69.3
09

Bevacco

Dine-in restaurant with direct and online ordering options

Bevacco is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York. It offers dine-in services and allows customers to order via phone or third-party apps.

PROS
  • The restaurant provides multiple convenient ordering methods for customers.
  • Bevacco facilitates easy reservation booking through the Resy platform.
CONS
  • Large indoor parties require contacting the restaurant directly for reservations.
Best for
groups of six or more
Where it falls short
Large indoor parties require contacting the restaurant directly for reservations.
Pick something else if
you need to book large indoor parties instantly online.
69.0
10

Eataly - SoHo

Restaurant and Italian marketplace in New York

Eataly SoHo operates as both a restaurant and an Italian marketplace. It offers extended sales on grocery items including free tiramisu candles.

PROS
  • The restaurant provides hands-on pasta classes and wine tastings.
  • Eataly - SoHo helps design intimate dinners or large galas.
Best for
Italian food enthusiasts
67.6

Put your company on this ranking

Contact us about one, two or three years. Nothing recurring.

Positions #4 to #10 are available on request. Contact us.

Not on this ranking?

Tell us about your company and we will reply by email.

Frequently asked questions

What are the best Italian restaurants in New York?

Coletta Italian Vegan Restaurant ranks first on Lister. Coletta is an intimate vegan and kosher dining experience in Gramercy, NYC. It offers a fresh culinary perspective on Italian cuisine with brick oven pizzas and fresh pastas.

What are the top 10 Italian restaurants in New York?

1. Coletta Italian Vegan Restaurant; 2. Da Claudio; 3. Ainslie Bowery; 4. Da Nico; 5. Carbone; 6. Fossetta; 7. Fiat Café; 8. Bacaro; 9. Bevacco; 10. Eataly - SoHo.

Who are these italian restaurants built for?

Ainslie Bowery says it is built for Private events and large groups, and Da Nico for families and couples seeking authentic Italian dining. Bacaro says it is built for lingering conversations, and Bevacco for groups of six or more.

What should a buyer check before signing up?

Carbone states that the restaurant may refuse entry to guests who are not sufficiently well-presented, and Bevacco that large indoor parties require contacting the restaurant directly for reservations. Those are the limits each restaurant publishes itself, not a full account of any plan.

Sources

Where we checked each company's facts, and when.

Sources for 5 more companies

Some links on Lister are affiliate links. Rankings are not affected.

Related rankings

Want your company on a Lister ranking?

Tell us about it and we will reply by email.

Contact us to get listed