Curated top 10 rankings of everything
HOME/RESTAURANTS/TORONTO/ITALIAN RESTAURANTS IN TORONTO

Best Italian Restaurants in Toronto in 2026

10 restaurants ranked, each with a short verdict.

Updated · How we rank

VERIFIEDLISTER SCORE · UPDATED Get your company ranked

Key takeaways

  • Top pick: Bar Romy, best for: Casual Italian dining in Toronto. 855 m from the centre of Toronto.
  • Also near the top: Mercatto, best for: diners seeking diverse Italian heritage experiences; and Vagabondo Restobar, best for: private events.
  • How it was ranked: 10 restaurants compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%). Each verdict is below.

Best Italian restaurants in Toronto: Top 10 Ranked. Bar Romy ranks first, with a Lister Score of 80.7.

Bar Romy ranks first here: it welcomes walk-in guests without reservations. Mercatto is built for diners seeking diverse Italian heritage experiences, and offers menus featuring both classic and reimagined Italian dishes. Vagabondo Restobar serves private events, and allows booking of the whole venue for private events.
Best Italian Restaurants in Toronto in 2026, compared
RANKENTRYBEST FORSCORE
1Bar Romy855 m from the centre of Toronto–80.7
2Mercatto787 m from the centre of Torontodiners seeking diverse Italian heritage experiences79.0
3Vagabondo Restobar1.2 km from the centre of Torontoprivate events73.5
4Amano Trattoria695 m from the centre of Torontospontaneous nights out or casual drinks73.3
5Hothouse Restaurant & Bar974 m from the centre of Torontogroups seeking shared plates72.3
6Elm Street Italian Deli470 m from the centre of Toronto–72.0
7Valens774 m from the centre of Torontocasual diners seeking relaxed atmosphere and large portions71.0
8Bar Ardo1.1 km from the centre of Torontonights meant to be remembered69.9
9Constantine1.7 km from the centre of Torontointimate dinners67.7
10Aria1.1 km from the centre of Torontobusiness lunches and post-event dinners67.6
CURATED · UPDATED HOW WE RANK →
Not on this ranking?

Tell us about your company and we will reply by email.

How to choose

Start from what you need it for. Where each entry fits best:

Each entry's Lister Score on this ranking weighs fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%).

Each entry's full verdict is below.

The ranking, in detail

01

Bar Romy

Neighbourhood Italian soul at an iconic intersection

Bar Romy is a casual Italian restaurant located in Toronto's Entertainment District. It specialises in classic dishes such as sandwiches, pizza, and handmade pasta.

PROS
  • The restaurant welcomes walk-in guests without reservations.
  • Bar Romy operates seven days a week.
Best for
Casual Italian dining in Toronto
Pick something else if
you require a guaranteed table at a specific time.
80.7
02

Mercatto

Inspired Italian hospitality since 1998

Mercatto celebrates Italian culinary tradition across four distinct downtown locations.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers menus featuring both classic and reimagined Italian dishes.
  • Mercatto unites its locations with a shared passion for wine and food.
Best for
diners seeking diverse Italian heritage experiences
79.0
03

Vagabondo Restobar

Give your guests something delicious to talk about.

Vagabondo Restobar is a Toronto venue offering lunch specials and private event spaces. Guests can book the whole venue or semi-private rooms for special occasions.

PROS
  • The restaurant allows booking of the whole venue for private events.
  • Vagabondo Restobar offers takeout and delivery via UberEats.
CONS
  • Online reservations are not final until confirmed by the team.
Best for
private events
Where it falls short
Online reservations are not final until confirmed by the team.
Pick something else if
you need guaranteed instant booking confirmation.
73.5
04

Amano Trattoria

No pretense. Just really good food and honest drinks.

Notte Ristorante is Toronto's aperitivo-led Italian trattoria. It offers impeccable cooking and dim candlelight.

PROS
  • The restaurant makes its pasta fresh every day.
  • The restaurant provides daily happy hour wines and cocktails.
Best for
spontaneous nights out or casual drinks
73.3
05

Hothouse Restaurant & Bar

Gather, Share and Savour Mediterranean dining

Hothouse Restaurant & Bar serves Mediterranean cuisine in downtown Toronto. It focuses on connection and sharing meals with friends.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers an iconic Sunday Brunch Buffet with live jazz music.
  • The restaurant features a loyalty programme called the Frequency Club.
Best for
groups seeking shared plates
72.3
06

Elm Street Italian Deli

Italian deli with convenient ordering options

Elm Street Italian Deli operates multiple locations in Toronto. It serves customers from its Eaton Centre and Queen Street East outlets.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers extended hours at its Leslieville location.
  • The restaurant provides a dedicated food hall presence at Queen’s Cross.
Where it falls short
The original Elm Street location closes earlier than other branches.
Pick something else if
you need late Sunday dining at the Queen Street outlet.
72.0
07

Valens

Global fusion dining in the heart of downtown Toronto

Valens is situated in Toronto's Baldwin Village and offers a selection of global fusion cuisine. The menu features items such as aged steaks, seafood, and homemade desserts served in generous portions.

PROS
  • The restaurant serves exceptional food with excellent service and a full bar.
  • The restaurant provides a warm atmosphere with a scenic front patio covered by leaves.
Best for
casual diners seeking relaxed atmosphere and large portions
71.0
08

Bar Ardo

Inspired by the passion for the Sicilian lifestyle

Bar Ardo is a trendy cocktail lounge and restaurant on King Street East. It offers small plates for cocktail hour and larger shareable dishes for memorable nights.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers a menu crafted by renowned Chef Roberto Marotta.
  • Bar Ardo provides a carefully curated cocktail and mocktail experience.
Best for
nights meant to be remembered
Pick something else if
you need standard full-course dining.
69.9
09

Constantine

Mediterranean dining in downtown Toronto

Constantine celebrates diverse Mediterranean cuisine within the Anndore House Hotel. It cultivates an intimate and inviting atmosphere for diners in downtown Toronto.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers diverse Mediterranean cuisine from distinct regions.
  • The restaurant cultivates an intimate and inviting atmosphere.
Best for
intimate dinners
Where it falls short
It is located inside The Anndore House Hotel, which may not suit diners seeking a standalone restaurant experience.
Pick something else if
you prefer a standalone venue.
67.7
10

Aria

Authentic italian fine dining and unique event experience

Aria Ristorante provides authentic Italian fine dining in a contemporary urban setting. It is owned by the proprietors of Noce Restaurant, which has set standards for over twenty years.

PROS
  • The restaurant offers a wide range of dishes paired with various wines.
  • Aria accommodates private parties and business lunches in a variety of formats.
Best for
business lunches and post-event dinners
67.6

Put your company on this ranking

Contact us about one, two or three years. Nothing recurring.

Positions #4 to #10 are available on request. Contact us.

Not on this ranking?

Tell us about your company and we will reply by email.

Frequently asked questions

What are the best Italian restaurants in Toronto?

Bar Romy ranks first on Lister. Bar Romy is a casual Italian restaurant located in Toronto's Entertainment District. It specialises in classic dishes such as sandwiches, pizza, and handmade pasta.

What are the top 10 Italian restaurants in Toronto?

1. Bar Romy; 2. Mercatto; 3. Vagabondo Restobar; 4. Amano Trattoria; 5. Hothouse Restaurant & Bar; 6. Elm Street Italian Deli; 7. Valens; 8. Bar Ardo; 9. Constantine; 10. Aria.

Who are these italian restaurants built for?

Mercatto says it is built for diners seeking diverse Italian heritage experiences, and Vagabondo Restobar for private events. Amano Trattoria says it is built for spontaneous nights out or casual drinks, and Hothouse Restaurant & Bar for groups seeking shared plates.

What should a buyer check before signing up?

Vagabondo Restobar states that online reservations are not final until confirmed by the team. Those are the limits each restaurant publishes itself, not a full account of any plan.

Sources

Where we checked each company's facts, and when.

Sources for 5 more companies

Some links on Lister are affiliate links. Rankings are not affected.

Related rankings

Want your company on a Lister ranking?

Tell us about it and we will reply by email.

Contact us to get listed