Lister has one ranking of hotels in Madison so far: Hotels in Madison. It was last verified on 1 Nov 2026.
The top three of Hotels in Madison
The Saddlery Madison
The Saddlery Madison ranks first on Hotels in Madison, with a Lister Score of 81.9.
The Saddlery Madison offers fully furnished short and long term rentals in downtown Madison. It provides boutique style accommodation with state of the art amenities.
Edgewater Hotel
Edgewater Hotel ranks second on Hotels in Madison, with a Lister Score of 81.5.
Situated on the shores of Lake Mendota in Madison, this hotel offers an urban resort experience. It features 202 rooms with breathtaking lake views and luxury amenities.
Governor's Mansion Inn
Governor's Mansion Inn ranks third on Hotels in Madison, with a Lister Score of 75.6.
This historic boutique hotel is situated in downtown Madison on the shore of Lake Mendota.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best hotels in Madison?
The Saddlery Madison ranks first on Hotels in Madison, with a Lister Score of 81.9, ahead of Edgewater Hotel and Governor's Mansion Inn.
How many rankings cover hotels in Madison?
One so far, Hotels in Madison, linked from this page. It was last verified on 1 Nov 2026.
How does Lister score hotels in Madison?
Each entry here has a Lister Score out of 100. Rankings built from Lister's directory score what each company publishes on its own site: how well it meets the ranking's selection rule (40), the evidence on its site or, for a ranking tied to a place, how close it is to the center (20), how complete its published facts are (20), and one signal chosen for the category (20). The panel on each ranking shows the rubric it used.