Top pick:The Saddlery Madison, best for: business travellers and families seeking extended stays. Unrated, 537 m from the centre of Madison.
Also near the top:Edgewater Hotel, best for: leisure travellers seeking lakefront relaxation and city exploration; and Governor's Mansion Inn, best for: Budget travelers seeking downtown lodging.
How it was ranked:10 hotels compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and star rating (20%). Each verdict is below.
Best Hotels in Madison: Top 10 Ranked. The Saddlery Madison ranks first, with a Lister Score of 81.9.
The Saddlery Madison takes the top spot on this list: it welcomes pets and provides convenient in unit laundry facilities. Edgewater Hotel is built for leisure travellers seeking lakefront relaxation and city exploration, and holds a AAA Four Diamond Rating and regional accolades. Governor's Mansion Inn offers complimentary coffee and scones each morning.
Elevated downtown Madison living for short and long term rentals
The Saddlery Madison offers fully furnished short and long term rentals in downtown Madison. It provides boutique style accommodation with state of the art amenities.
The Marquette Hotel serves as a launchpad for independent travellers in Madison's Williamson-Marquette neighbourhood. Guests can access local art, dining and creative energy directly from the premises.
PROS
The hotel uses green, natural and non-toxic cleaning products.
The hotel employs high-energy small fixtures and LED lighting.
Madison’s best kept secret for bed, breakfast and beyond
Hotel Ruby Marie offers a unique blend of modern luxury and Victorian charm in Madison. It invites guests to stray away from standard corporate experiences. The property is locally owned and operated.
PROS
The hotel includes breakfast, happy hour, and complimentary parking with every stay.
The hotel provides onsite dining, takeout options, and late-night food and drink selections.
Exceptional value with homestyle comfort in Madison
This newly renovated hotel offers homestyle comfort near major business districts and the University of Wisconsin-Madison. It is conveniently located off the West Beltline Highway for easy access to local attractions.
PROS
The hotel provides free breakfast, a gym, and pool.
Baymont by Wyndham Madison West/Middleton WI West includes microwaves and refrigerators in all rooms.
The Saddlery Madison ranks first on Lister. The Saddlery Madison offers fully furnished short and long term rentals in downtown Madison. It provides boutique style accommodation with state of the art amenities.
What are the top 10 Hotels in Madison?
1. The Saddlery Madison; 2. Edgewater Hotel; 3. Governor's Mansion Inn; 4. Marquette Hotel; 5. Hotel Ruby Marie; 6. InnTowner; 7. Baymont by Wyndham Madison West/Middleton WI West; 8. Days Inn Madison Northeast/Windsor; 9. La Quinta Inn & Suites Madison American Center; 10. Baymont Inn & Suites Inn & Suites by Wyndham Madison.
Who are these hotels built for?
The Saddlery Madison says it is built for business travellers and families seeking extended stays, and Edgewater Hotel for leisure travellers seeking lakefront relaxation and city exploration. Marquette Hotel says it is built for independent travellers, and Hotel Ruby Marie for travelers seeking local culture and nightlife.