Top pick:Cafe Bionda, best for: family gatherings. 2.2 km from the centre of Chicago.
Also near the top:Siena Tavern, best for: social gatherings seeking a polished atmosphere; and Sofi Restaurant, best for: Diners seeking traditional northern Italian cuisine.
How it was ranked:10 restaurants compared, each scored on fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%). Each verdict is below.
Best Italian restaurants in Chicago: Top 10 Ranked. Cafe Bionda ranks first, with a Lister Score of 79.8.
Cafe Bionda leads this ranking for family gatherings, and provides amazing service with friendly and personable staff members. Siena Tavern is built for social gatherings seeking a polished atmosphere, and combines made-from-scratch menu items with sophisticated hospitality. Sofi Restaurant prepares freshly made pastas in house using imported ingredients.
Best Italian Restaurants in Chicago in 2026, compared
Each entry's Lister Score on this ranking weighs fit to the list (40%), distance from the center (20%), published detail (20%) and published rating (20%).
Cafe Bionda is a charming, old-school Italian restaurant located in Chicago’s South Loop. It offers an unforgettable culinary journey steeped in authentic Italian charm for its guests.
Modern Italian cuisine rooted in Italy, raised in Chicago
Rooted in Italy and raised in Chicago, Siena Tavern offers sophisticated Italian dining. The restaurant provides a comfortable, vibrant, social and polished all-day experience.
Authentic imported Italian cuisine made from the heart
Nestled in Chicago's historic Printer's Row, Sofi Italian specialises in traditional northern Italian cuisine. It offers a perfect mix of classic food and a contemporary atmosphere.
Fontano's Pizza and Subs offers homemade pizza alongside its renowned submarine sandwiches. The establishment also serves pasta and specialty items to complement its core menu.
PROS
The restaurant has been rated the best sandwich in America by Zagat.
The restaurant provides a diverse menu including homemade pizza and pasta.
CONS
The restaurant is closed on Sundays, limiting weekend dining options.
Ciccio Mio offers classic Italian cuisine within one of Chicago's most intimate settings. The restaurant welcomes parties of up to six guests for reservations.
PROS
The restaurant accepts reservations for parties of up to six guests.
The restaurant provides lounge seating available for walk-in guests.
CONS
The restaurant does not have a private dining room or event space.
Best for
intimate dinners for small groups
Where it falls short
It lacks private dining rooms or event space for larger gatherings.
Trivoli Tavern is a Hogsalt supper club on Green Street in Chicago's West Loop, a clubby, old-school tavern built around seafood, steaks and its famous prime rib.
Best for
Seafood and steak lovers
Where it falls short
The Lobster Bar accepts walk-ins only.
Pick something else if
you need a guaranteed reservation.
59.8
Put your company on this ranking
Contact us about one, two or three years. Nothing recurring.
Cafe Bionda ranks first on Lister. Cafe Bionda is a charming, old-school Italian restaurant located in Chicago’s South Loop. It offers an unforgettable culinary journey steeped in authentic Italian charm for its guests.
What are the top 10 Italian restaurants in Chicago?
1. Cafe Bionda; 2. Siena Tavern; 3. Sofi Restaurant; 4. Petterino's; 5. Gibsons Italia; 6. Fontano's Pizza and Subs; 7. Ciccio Mio; 8. Italian VIllage; 9. Harry Caray's Italian Steakhouse; 10. Trivoli Tavern.
Who are these italian restaurants built for?
Cafe Bionda says it is built for family gatherings, and Siena Tavern for social gatherings seeking a polished atmosphere. Petterino's says it is built for diners seeking a vibrant social hub, and Fontano's Pizza and Subs for Sandwich enthusiasts seeking award-winning quality.
What should a buyer check before signing up?
Fontano's Pizza and Subs states that the restaurant is closed on Sundays, limiting weekend dining options, and Ciccio Mio that the restaurant does not have a private dining room or event space. Italian VIllage states that the Village location is only accessible via stairs due to structural constraints. Those are the limits each restaurant publishes itself, not a full account of any plan.